Our Menu
Build Your Own Thin Crust Pizza
Cheese Only
$15.00/10″ Personal
$22.00/14″ Medium
$24.00/16″ Large
Regular Ingredients
$1.00/10″ Personal
$2.00/14″ Medium
$2.50/16″ Large
Premium Ingredients
$1.25/10″ Personal
$2.50/14″ Medium
$3.00/16″ Large
Choose from the Following fresh ingredients
Premium Ingredients:
Sausage • Pepperoni • Bacon • Ground Beef • Italian Beef • Canadian Bacon • Anchovies • Char-Grilled Chicken
Regular Ingredients:
Extra Cheese • Spinach • Onion • Broccoli • Mushrooms • Cauliflower • Pineapple • Fresh Garlic • Feta Cheese • Fresh Tomato • Green Pepper • Kalamata Olives • Black Olives • Green Olives • Giardiniera • Jalapeno
Gatsby’s makes each pizza to order with only the finest ingredients.
Please allow 20-30 minutes cooking time.
Gatsby’s Gourmet Pizzas
Sorry, NO SUBSTITUTIONS
Southwestern BBQ
$26.95/14″ Medium
$29.95/16″ Large
Grilled boneless chicken breast, red onions, mozzarella, and BBQ sauce
Garden Vegetable
$26.95/14″ Medium
$29.95/16″ Large
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives and spinach
Meat Lover’s (John’s Favorite)
$26.95/14″ Medium
$29.95/16″ Large
Sausage, Pepperoni, bacon, fresh tomato and extra cheese
Hot Honey
$26.95/14″ Medium
$29.95/16″ Large
Mozzarella, pepperoni, feta cheese & hot honey
Starters
Great bites to get the party started
Nachos
$15.95
Homemade tortilla chips smothered in a cheddar cheese sauce, topped with tomatoes, lettuce, black olives, chives, homemade guacamole, sour cream and a side of chunky salsa
With seasoned ground beef, spicy chicken, pork carnitas or BBQ pulled pork +$5.95
With seasoned ground beef, spicy chicken, pork carnitas or BBQ pulled pork +$5.95
Basket of French Fries
$4.95/Half Order
$7.95/Full Order
Plain, Seasoned or Cajun Style
With cheddar cheese sauce $8.95
With chili and cheddar cheese sauce $9.95
With baked mixed cheeses and bacon $10.95
With cheddar cheese sauce $8.95
With chili and cheddar cheese sauce $9.95
With baked mixed cheeses and bacon $10.95
Basket of Sweet Potato Fries
$6.95/Half Order
$9.95/Full Order
Plain, Seasoned, or Cajun
Basket of Onion Rings
$6.95/Half Order
$12.95/Full Order
Served with a side of homemade ranch
Basket of Breaded Mushrooms
$6.95/Half Order
$12.95/Full Order
Served with a side of homemade ranch
Basket of Fried Pickles
$7.95/Half Order
$12.95/Full Order
A basket of crispy fried pickle spears. Served with a side of our homemade ranch
Fried Combo Basket
$14.95
Breaded mushrooms, onion rings, and pickles with a side of homemade ranch. No substitutions
Basket of Cheese Curds
$13.95
Lightly breaded Wisconsin White Cheddar cheese curds served with a side of homemade ranch
Buffalo Chicken Quesadillas
$17.95
Grilled buffalo chicken & mixed cheeses inside a large flour tortilla with a side of ranch
Buffalo Chicken Tenders
$6.95/Half Order
$12.95/Full Order
Served with celery, carrots and your choice of bleu cheese or homemade ranch
Chicken Tenders
$6.50/Half Order (2)
$11.95/Full Order (4)
Golden-breaded all-white meat tenders served with your choice of homemade ranch, honey mustard, creamy chipotle or BBQ sauce
Chips & Salsa
$6.95
With homemade guacamole $11.95
Additional basket of chips $3.95
Additional basket of chips $3.95
Gatsby’s Famous Jumbo Chicken Wings
$15.95/8 Pieces
$20.95/12 Pieces
$39.95/24 Pieces
Buffalo(Hot), BBQ, Parmesan Garlic, Hot Honey Garlic or Plain served with homemade Ranch, carrots, and celery. No mix and match
Saganaki
$13.50
Flaming Greek goat cheese served with French bread
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
$11.95
Three large Bavarian style salted pretzel sticks served with a side of cheddar sauce
Hummus Veggie Plate
$13.95
Our homemade hummus served with warm pita bread, carrots, celery, and cucumbers
Bang Bang Shrimp
$15.95
Sauteed Shrimp tossed in our homemade sweet & spicy bang bang sauce. Served with garlic bread
Basket of Popcorn Shrimp
$6.95/Half Order
$11.95/Full Order
Crunchy fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$13.95
Chopped spinach & artichoke hearts in a creamy cheese dip, Served with pita bread and homemade tortilla chips
Chilled Vegetable Platter
$13.95
Carrots, celery, cauliflower, green peppers, cucumber and broccoli. Served with homemade ranch
Pick two vegetables a-la-carte $6.95
Pick two vegetables a-la-carte $6.95
Jumbo Potato Skins
$12.95
Three enormous potato skins topped with diced bacon and a melted cheese blend, served with a side of sour cream
Fiesta Tacos
$9.95
Your choice of two soft flour or two soft corn tortillas filled with seasoned ground beef or spicy chicken, cilantro & onion mix, shredded mozzarella and a side of salsa verde
With steak or pork carnitas $12.95
With steak or pork carnitas $12.95
Santa Fe Egg Rolls
$13.95
Egg rolls stuffed with smoked chicken, corn, black bean salsa, and jack cheese, served with a honey mustard dip
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
$7.95/Half Order
$13.95/Full Order
Eight mozzarella cheese sticks golden breaded, served with our own marinara sauce
Cheese Quesadillas
$13.95
Flour tortillas stuffed with blended cheeses, fresh tomatoes, and chives. Served with a side of sour cream, salsa, and homemade guacamole
With grilled chicken, carnitas or steak $17.95
With grilled chicken, carnitas or steak $17.95
Homemade Beef Chili
$7.95
With blended cheeses, onions and jalapeño peppers
Today’s Homemade Soup
$5.50
Side Salad
$8.50
Burgers
Hand-packed 10 oz. Grass-fed black angus ground beef patty grilled to order! All burgers come with complimentary fries and a pickle.
Upgrade your side for only $2.75
Upgrade options: side salad, sweet potato fries, onion rings, Spanish rice, or homemade soup
Bread choices: Brioche Bun, Marble Rye, White, Multigrain
Extra cheese $1.00: American, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Swiss, PepperJack
Add Smoked Bacon: $3.75 | Add Avocado: $3.75 | Add Fried Egg (over easy): $2.75
The Great Gatsby
$19.95
Our Specialty! House blend of chopped onions, green peppers, and spices topped with your choice of cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato and onion
Sunrise Burger
$19.95
Bacon, fried egg, grilled onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce & tomato
Bacon Cheeseburger
$18.95
Topped with bacon, your choice of cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato & onion
Diablo Burger
$19.95
Guacamole, chipotle mayo & pepperjack cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
Bleu Cheeseburger
$18.95
Blue cheese crumbles and diced bacon, lettuce, tomato & onion
Patty Melt
$18.95
Grilled onions and your choice of cheese served on grilled light rye
Texas BBQ Burger
$18.95
BBQ pulled pork, jalapenos, cheddar cheese & crispy onion strings
Salads
From our garden to your table. All salads include garlic bread and your choice of dressing on the side.
Dressing choices: Homemade Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Caesar, House Greek, 1000 Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Honey Mustard, Vinegar & Olive Oil.
Add avocado $3.75
Add grilled chicken $6.95
Add grilled steak $9.95
GATSBY’S House Salad
$14.95
Chocked full of mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, shredded carrots and cucumbers
Greek Salad
$17.75
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, cucumbers, feta cheese, shredded carrots, Greek olives and anchovies, with George’s Greek dressing on the side
Caesar Salad
$14.95
Crisp Romaine lettuce tossed in caesar dressing with parmesan, homemade croutons, and tomato
Taco Salad
$18.95
Homemade tortilla shell filled with lettuce, blended cheeses, tomatoes, chives and black olives, topped with sour cream, homemade guacamole and your choice of seasoned ground beef or char-grilled chicken. Served with a side of chunky salsa
BLT Pasta Salad
$18.95
Shredded romaine lettuce, chopped bacon, diced tomatoes & our homemade ranch tossed in pasta
Wraps
All wraps are made with a large flour tortilla and come with complimentary fries and a pickle.
Upgrade your side for only $2.75
Upgrade options: side salad, sweet potato fries, onion rings, Spanish rice, or homemade soup.
Add Smoked Bacon: $3.75 | Add Avocado: $3.75
Reuben Wrap
$20.95
Thinly sliced homemade hot corned beef with swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1000 Island
Turkey Club Wrap
$19.95
Thick sliced turkey breast, blended cheeses, crispy bacon, fresh shredded lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$19.95
Diced char-grilled chicken breast tossed with chopped romaine lettuce, caesar dressing and parmesan
Chicken Club Wrap
$19.95
Diced char-grilled chicken breast, blended cheeses, crispy bacon, fresh shredded lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise | Also available in cajun, creamy chipotle, or BBQ style
Mediterranean Chicken Wrap
$19.95
Diced grilled chicken, feta cheese, greek dressing, fresh shredded lettuce, grilled onion, peppers and black olives
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$19.95
All-white meat chicken tenders diced and tossed in our famous hot sauce with homemade ranch, fresh shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and blended cheeses. Served with a side of homemade ranch
Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap
$19.95
All-white meat chicken tenders diced and tossed in honey mustard sauce, fresh shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and blended cheeses. Served with a side of honey mustard
Sandwiches
All sandwiches come with complimentary fries and a pickle.
Upgrade your side for only $2.75
Upgrade options: side salad, sweet potato fries, onion rings, Spanish rice, or homemade soup
Bread choices: Brioche Bun, Marble Rye, White, Multigrain
Extra cheese $1.00: American, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Swiss, PepperJack
Add Smoked Bacon: $3.75 | Add Avocado: $3.75
Italian Beef
$19.95
Seasoned beef piled high on garlic bread and served with grilled green peppers, melted mozzarella and a side of au jus and giardiniera
Chicken Avocado Melt
$18.95
Sliced avocado and melted mozzarella cheese over a chicken breast on a French roll
New York Style Reuben
$20.50
Homemade corned beef open faced, topped with Swiss and sauerkraut and served over 1000 Island dressing on light rye
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
$18.95
6 oz. golden fried chicken breast topped with shredded lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles & chipotle mayo, served on a brioche bun
Buffalo Chicken
$18.95
Grilled or fried chicken breast smothered in our famous wing sauce, fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with a side of homemade Ranch
Hummwich
$16.95
Toasted wheat bread stuffed with our homemade hummus, sliced avocado, cucumbers, and crumbled Feta cheese
Chicken Club
$18.95
An 8 ounce chicken breast grilled to perfection with crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and mayonnaise. Also available in buffalo, chipotle, cajun style
The Big Cheese
$14.95
American cheese stuffed with bacon and tomato between two slices of grilled white toast
Classic BLT Club
$17.95
Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, sliced tomato and mayonnaise
Turkey Club
$18.95
Thick sliced turkey breast, crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and mayonnaise
New York Steak Sandwich
$20.95
USDA Prime New York strip steak grilled to order on a garlic French roll with fresh lettuce, tomato & onion. With a choice of crust : Parmesan, Bleu Cheese, or Peppercorn.
Philly Steak Sandwich
$20.95
Sliced USDA New York strip steak grilled to order and topped with grilled mushrooms, onions, peppers and mozzarella cheese on a garlic French roll
Boneless Chicken Wing Dinner
$18.95
8 pieces tossed with your choice of Buffalo, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Hot Honey Garlic, Sweet Teriyaki, Mango Habanero, Jamaican Jerk. Served with homemade Ranch or Bleu cheese, carrots, celery and Fries
Baked Gourmet Mac N’ Cheese
$17.95
Cavatappi pasta with a rich creamy cheese blend, chopped bacon, baked with breadcrumbs. Served with Garlic bread
Add Grilled or Fried Chicken $6.00
Add Grilled or Fried Buffalo Chicken $6.00
Add Mushrooms, Jalapeño or Fresh Garlic $2.00 (each)
Add Grilled or Fried Chicken $6.00
Add Grilled or Fried Buffalo Chicken $6.00
Add Mushrooms, Jalapeño or Fresh Garlic $2.00 (each)
Chicken N’ Waffles
$18.95
2 Thick waffles, 3 Chicken tenders, diced bacon, chives & hot honey syrup. Topped with powdered sugar. Served with Fries
Desserts
Satisfy your cravings
Nutella Puffs
$10.95
Four NUTELLA® stuffed pastry puffs, dusted with powdered sugar, served with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup
Cronuts
$10.95
Four croissant donuts dusted with powdered sugar, served with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup
OREO Cookie PIE
$10.95
An OREO® cookie lovers dream of white & milk chocolate cream, with OREO® chunks, with dark chocolate drizzle
Snickers Blitz
$10.95
The original pie that eats like a candy bar! Large chunks of Snickers® bars, fudgy brownie, caramel, peanuts and a tart cream cheese filling
Kids Menu
All kids meals are served with complimentary fries. Ages 12 and under only, please
Hot Dog
$8.95
Kids Burger
$8.95
Chicken Tenders
$8.95
Grilled Cheese
$8.95
Popcorn Shrimp
$8.95
Kraft Mac ‘N’ Cheese
$8.95